I spent the day yesterday in Respirology clinic. I found it to be great practice at reviewing how to approach PFTs, as I hadn't read one in quite some time. We saw a variety of patients with COPD, asthma, and also a1-antitrypsin deficiency. I learned that in these patients they are often left undiagnosed for quite some time since they may present like someone with COPD. However, they are generally younger when they first present with symptoms. We saw a 54-year-old patient yesterdays with PFTs that would suggest emphysema but in fact he had undiagnosed a1-antitrypsin deficiency. I think this was an important learning point to keep in mind, and to remember to always keep a broad differential.
- JD
Friday, March 30, 2018
Thursday, March 29, 2018
Teaching Session
As part of my medical education selective, today I had the opportunity to hold a teaching session for third year clerks. I decided to hold my teaching session on acute burn management as it's an important and relevant topic to know, but also one that I find interesting.
I decided to structure my lesson using a combination of both didactic and interactive activities. I first presented general background on burns etiology, diagnosis and management (specifically trauma ABCs). Throughout the didactic session I also asked the clerks questions to get them involved in the lesson. For the interactive component, I presented patient cases to allow the students to apply the content they had just learned. Using burn assessment sheets that are often used in the trauma bay, the students applied the Rule of 9's and calculated fluid resuscitation for the patient cases.
As a previous teacher, I find the opportunity to teach others very rewarding and exciting. I found this to be a great activity that allowed me to review my knowledge and also find an fun way to share that with others. I hope that I will be able to continue teaching medical students in the future.
- JD
I decided to structure my lesson using a combination of both didactic and interactive activities. I first presented general background on burns etiology, diagnosis and management (specifically trauma ABCs). Throughout the didactic session I also asked the clerks questions to get them involved in the lesson. For the interactive component, I presented patient cases to allow the students to apply the content they had just learned. Using burn assessment sheets that are often used in the trauma bay, the students applied the Rule of 9's and calculated fluid resuscitation for the patient cases.
As a previous teacher, I find the opportunity to teach others very rewarding and exciting. I found this to be a great activity that allowed me to review my knowledge and also find an fun way to share that with others. I hope that I will be able to continue teaching medical students in the future.
- JD
Wednesday, March 28, 2018
Ambulatory Medicine
Ambulatory settings are a great place for medical education, and tons of potential to facilitate teaching. However, it does require some preparations in advance to ensure that learners get the best experience and patient care isn't disrupted.
When preceptors aren't aware of incoming learners, many issues can arise. The clinic may be too busy for the preceptor to balance teaching vs. service, causing a lot of tension. There may not be enough space for the student to use to perform their own examinations. Patients may be less than welcoming of the sudden learner, especially if they're in a hurry and weren't informed. Other staff may be disoriented because of the extra personnel, and not being familiar with their roles as part of the team. Likely, the preceptor and student would not have had a chance to go through learning objectives and determine expectations for the experience.
However, when proper preparations can be made, students can have a great learning experience. Health care is moving away from hospitals and towards ambulatory and community settings, so it will be helpful for students to learn within the setting to better reflect what they'll be practicing. Ambulatory settings also provide a broad range of patients for students to see, and often undifferentiated symptoms to challenge problem solving and medical knowledge. If a preceptor can be informed in advance of a learner they will be taking on, along with their medical background, they can ensure that there is adequate space for the learner to see patients and research medical information. By informing staff of the student and their roles on the team, the student may be able to have more experiences working with different team members, and find themselves in a more welcoming environment. Having staff gain patient consent to have a medical learner ahead of time, or having informational sheets in the waiting areas, can allow the learner to have a more productive encounter with patients. Clinic days with a learner can also be scheduled so that time will be available for case discussions and teaching, as well as regular feedback.
These are not the only ways, but just a few ways in which ambulatory learning experiences can be optimized for learners. Hopefully, ambulatory teaching settings can be continuously improved to help learners become competent physicians.
-SC-
When preceptors aren't aware of incoming learners, many issues can arise. The clinic may be too busy for the preceptor to balance teaching vs. service, causing a lot of tension. There may not be enough space for the student to use to perform their own examinations. Patients may be less than welcoming of the sudden learner, especially if they're in a hurry and weren't informed. Other staff may be disoriented because of the extra personnel, and not being familiar with their roles as part of the team. Likely, the preceptor and student would not have had a chance to go through learning objectives and determine expectations for the experience.
However, when proper preparations can be made, students can have a great learning experience. Health care is moving away from hospitals and towards ambulatory and community settings, so it will be helpful for students to learn within the setting to better reflect what they'll be practicing. Ambulatory settings also provide a broad range of patients for students to see, and often undifferentiated symptoms to challenge problem solving and medical knowledge. If a preceptor can be informed in advance of a learner they will be taking on, along with their medical background, they can ensure that there is adequate space for the learner to see patients and research medical information. By informing staff of the student and their roles on the team, the student may be able to have more experiences working with different team members, and find themselves in a more welcoming environment. Having staff gain patient consent to have a medical learner ahead of time, or having informational sheets in the waiting areas, can allow the learner to have a more productive encounter with patients. Clinic days with a learner can also be scheduled so that time will be available for case discussions and teaching, as well as regular feedback.
These are not the only ways, but just a few ways in which ambulatory learning experiences can be optimized for learners. Hopefully, ambulatory teaching settings can be continuously improved to help learners become competent physicians.
-SC-
Complication
Yesterday in dermatology clinic I was able to see an interesting patient case of alopecia. The patient experienced some alopecia previously that resolved a few years ago with topicals . Now, she has started to notice loss of hair on her bilateral temples. She has no PMH or FHx of autoimmune or dermatological conditions.
On examination, the initial location of alopecia on her crown had resolved with good hair growth. On her temples, however, there was evidence of scarring alopecia. Interestingly, the patient also had two symmetrical scars in the same area where she had a previous facelift in another country. Our plan for this patient was to schedule a biopsy to confirm whether or not she had any remaining hair follicles in the area that would be amenable to treatment.
I found this case especially interesting because of the mixed presentation of both scarring and non scarring alopecia. Also the incidental finding of a 10-year-old scar in the same area as her new symptoms seems strange given the length of time between surgery and symptoms.
-JD
On examination, the initial location of alopecia on her crown had resolved with good hair growth. On her temples, however, there was evidence of scarring alopecia. Interestingly, the patient also had two symmetrical scars in the same area where she had a previous facelift in another country. Our plan for this patient was to schedule a biopsy to confirm whether or not she had any remaining hair follicles in the area that would be amenable to treatment.
I found this case especially interesting because of the mixed presentation of both scarring and non scarring alopecia. Also the incidental finding of a 10-year-old scar in the same area as her new symptoms seems strange given the length of time between surgery and symptoms.
-JD
Tuesday, March 27, 2018
SNAPPS
SNAPPS is an approach for medical trainees to present a case to their preceptors, in a way that helps them learn and be concise. This would've been a very useful tool for me to have known about earlier in my medical school career as I always struggled to give concise presentation.
S - summarize your case by presenting only pertinent information
N - narrow your differential to the top 3 or less
A - analyze your differential with evidence that supports and doesn't support it from your encounter
P - probe your preceptor (your time to ask questions!)
P - plan your management
S - self-directed learning topic (what steps can you take to improve?)
As I feel this is a very useful tool, and I didn't come across it until this selective, I've decided to teach CC3 students how to practice using this tool by going through cases with them.
Hopefully they find it helpful as well!
-SC-
S - summarize your case by presenting only pertinent information
N - narrow your differential to the top 3 or less
A - analyze your differential with evidence that supports and doesn't support it from your encounter
P - probe your preceptor (your time to ask questions!)
P - plan your management
S - self-directed learning topic (what steps can you take to improve?)
As I feel this is a very useful tool, and I didn't come across it until this selective, I've decided to teach CC3 students how to practice using this tool by going through cases with them.
Hopefully they find it helpful as well!
-SC-
Monday, March 26, 2018
What IS the guideline?
The Canadian Task Force's recommendations on diseases screening has been taught to my class throughout our medical school. Especially for me, as I'll be pursuing family medicine, it has been a very commonly referenced resource by me and many physicians I have worked with. Although most of the time, the recommendations are in agreement with what is practiced, there are also suggestions that don't quite sit well with all physicians.
During my endoscopy clinic today, the resident and staff both informed me how their specialty of Gastroenterology still recommends colonoscopy as a screening tool, despite the Canadian Task Force stating otherwise. When I hear conflicting information such as this, I wonder what choices I will end up making when I am practicing independently. I think this is when it's important to try and understand what priorities lie behind the guidelines I am reading. For example, the Canadian Task Force's guidelines are not only based on population studies, but also taking into account, economic efficiencies. Therefore, from its point of view, a colonoscopy is not the most cost-efficient tool for screening purposes, but from a physician's point of view, it is the best method of finding any pathology within the GI tract.
This is something I believe medical students should be taught, to accurately weigh the pros and cons of each recommendation they reference so that they can make choices that are most beneficial to each patient. Since we're taught to know the "guidelines" to pass exams, it should be made clear to us as learners, what really matters in real-life practice.
-SC-
During my endoscopy clinic today, the resident and staff both informed me how their specialty of Gastroenterology still recommends colonoscopy as a screening tool, despite the Canadian Task Force stating otherwise. When I hear conflicting information such as this, I wonder what choices I will end up making when I am practicing independently. I think this is when it's important to try and understand what priorities lie behind the guidelines I am reading. For example, the Canadian Task Force's guidelines are not only based on population studies, but also taking into account, economic efficiencies. Therefore, from its point of view, a colonoscopy is not the most cost-efficient tool for screening purposes, but from a physician's point of view, it is the best method of finding any pathology within the GI tract.
This is something I believe medical students should be taught, to accurately weigh the pros and cons of each recommendation they reference so that they can make choices that are most beneficial to each patient. Since we're taught to know the "guidelines" to pass exams, it should be made clear to us as learners, what really matters in real-life practice.
-SC-
Sunday, March 25, 2018
Interesting Case
During my time in the TB clinic earlier this week I had the opportunity to see a very interesting case involving a patient at follow-up. Initially, the patient presented with large masses on her ears with no apparent cause. As an immigrant to Canada from a country with cases of leprosy, the patient was worked up for a variety of potential causes including both leprosy and also TB.
I found this to be an incredibly interesting case as I had never seen any cutaneous manifestations of TB before. Cutaneous lesions are relatively uncommon manifestations of TB and occur in only 1-2% of infected patients. The lesion appeared to be large, verrucous nodules, almost similar to keloids. In learning about TB in class, we are taught of extrapulmonary TB. However, I was amazed at how the physicians were able to come to a differential diagnosis including TB based on this appearance. I also found the case interesting as the treatment for potential leprosy would be counterproductive in treating TB, and vice versa. The physician decided to treat the patient empirically (despite all tests for M. tuberculosis being negative) with great improvement of the lesions at her follow-up visit. From this encounter I learned how insidious TB can be and to be reminded to always keep it on my differential.
-JD
I found this to be an incredibly interesting case as I had never seen any cutaneous manifestations of TB before. Cutaneous lesions are relatively uncommon manifestations of TB and occur in only 1-2% of infected patients. The lesion appeared to be large, verrucous nodules, almost similar to keloids. In learning about TB in class, we are taught of extrapulmonary TB. However, I was amazed at how the physicians were able to come to a differential diagnosis including TB based on this appearance. I also found the case interesting as the treatment for potential leprosy would be counterproductive in treating TB, and vice versa. The physician decided to treat the patient empirically (despite all tests for M. tuberculosis being negative) with great improvement of the lesions at her follow-up visit. From this encounter I learned how insidious TB can be and to be reminded to always keep it on my differential.
-JD
Thursday, March 22, 2018
Don't Just Refer!
I had the opportunity to work with an amazing dermatologist in his clinic today, and there were several important learning points to take away from the experience.
First, don't make assumptions because you've seen a similar case a hundred times. Just because a patient has what looks like a wart on the bottom of their foot, doesn't mean you can dismiss your other differentials. Make sure to rule out the melanoma or actinic keratosis. Despite having been practicing for so many years and seeing countless numbers of similar cases, the dermatologist still made sure give them conscious thought.
Second, we're here to provide medical advice and treatments to our patients but ultimately, the choice is up to the patient (given capacity is present). Once a patient is sure that they're making an informed decision, they shouldn't feel threatened or so pressured by their physician to start a treatment that they don't feel their concerns are listened to.
Lastly, no matter the resources that are available around us, we should continue to develop our own medical knowledge and skills and provide as much service as we can to our own patients before deferring them to someone else's expertise. We had seen many patients today coming in for simple cases such as acne or warts, where their family physician had not recommended a single treatment to them before referring them to the dermatologist. Even if specialists are much more accessible in more urban cities, generalists should remember that we're also equipped with the knowledge and tools to assist our patients with many of their concerns.
-SC-
First, don't make assumptions because you've seen a similar case a hundred times. Just because a patient has what looks like a wart on the bottom of their foot, doesn't mean you can dismiss your other differentials. Make sure to rule out the melanoma or actinic keratosis. Despite having been practicing for so many years and seeing countless numbers of similar cases, the dermatologist still made sure give them conscious thought.
Second, we're here to provide medical advice and treatments to our patients but ultimately, the choice is up to the patient (given capacity is present). Once a patient is sure that they're making an informed decision, they shouldn't feel threatened or so pressured by their physician to start a treatment that they don't feel their concerns are listened to.
Lastly, no matter the resources that are available around us, we should continue to develop our own medical knowledge and skills and provide as much service as we can to our own patients before deferring them to someone else's expertise. We had seen many patients today coming in for simple cases such as acne or warts, where their family physician had not recommended a single treatment to them before referring them to the dermatologist. Even if specialists are much more accessible in more urban cities, generalists should remember that we're also equipped with the knowledge and tools to assist our patients with many of their concerns.
-SC-
Morning Report Reflection
During today's morning report, I enjoyed the staff's use of personal reflection on the patient cases and one's self. The resident on-call chose a few interesting patients to discuss. This allowed each of us in the room to use the chief complaint to construct our own differential diagnoses followed by a discussion of the pertinent teaching points.
One of the most interesting aspects that I found was the staff's use of a summary table in discussing each of the patients. The headings were the following: ID, CC/summary, confidence about diagnosis (1-7), diagnosis (if confidence > 4) and area of difficulty surrounding the case. I really enjoyed the opportunity to reflect on one's own level of confidence in their differential as well as the difficulties in managing the case that may have contributed to this doubt. I think that this allows a lot of opportunity to learn from very difficult cases and perhaps change your thought process in the future when encountering a potential "zebra".
At the end of the morning report, the staff also asked everyone to take away a learning point from the discussion or an area in which you may want to review. Overall, I found it to be an insightful and interesting approach to morning report and I hope to incorporate some of these reflections in my future practice.
One of the most interesting aspects that I found was the staff's use of a summary table in discussing each of the patients. The headings were the following: ID, CC/summary, confidence about diagnosis (1-7), diagnosis (if confidence > 4) and area of difficulty surrounding the case. I really enjoyed the opportunity to reflect on one's own level of confidence in their differential as well as the difficulties in managing the case that may have contributed to this doubt. I think that this allows a lot of opportunity to learn from very difficult cases and perhaps change your thought process in the future when encountering a potential "zebra".
At the end of the morning report, the staff also asked everyone to take away a learning point from the discussion or an area in which you may want to review. Overall, I found it to be an insightful and interesting approach to morning report and I hope to incorporate some of these reflections in my future practice.
- JD
Wednesday, March 21, 2018
Differences in Medical School Structure
I recently returned to Toronto after an international selective in Argentina. One of the most noticeable differences between medical education in Canada and Argentina lies in the structure of the undergraduate medical program.
In Argentina, similar to the European system, students enter medical school directly from high school. The program is 6 years in length and involves solely theory and clinical observation. Medical students get no practical, hands-on experience until they graduate. After graduation, students are required to complete 1 year of "practical" work in a variety of specialties (similar to our clerkship years). After this, students begin residency.
In observing the first year residents on my surgical rotation I found it hard to believe that their involvement in the OR was similar to that of a clerk in Canada. Residents were shocked to hear that in our program we are assisting in surgeries and delivering babies from 3rd year. However, I think that the clinical knowledge of residents in Argentina was well above ours. They also seem to have an incredible amount of responsibility, even as a PGY1.
For myself, I enjoyed the opportunity to explore other areas of interest in university prior to medical school to ensure that I was making the right decision in pursuing Medicine. As a hands-on learner, I also enjoy the opportunity to have extensive practical experience in our final years of medical school. Nevertheless, I think that both structures have their pros and cons and perhaps a student's success would depend on his/her learning style.
-JD
In Argentina, similar to the European system, students enter medical school directly from high school. The program is 6 years in length and involves solely theory and clinical observation. Medical students get no practical, hands-on experience until they graduate. After graduation, students are required to complete 1 year of "practical" work in a variety of specialties (similar to our clerkship years). After this, students begin residency.
In observing the first year residents on my surgical rotation I found it hard to believe that their involvement in the OR was similar to that of a clerk in Canada. Residents were shocked to hear that in our program we are assisting in surgeries and delivering babies from 3rd year. However, I think that the clinical knowledge of residents in Argentina was well above ours. They also seem to have an incredible amount of responsibility, even as a PGY1.
For myself, I enjoyed the opportunity to explore other areas of interest in university prior to medical school to ensure that I was making the right decision in pursuing Medicine. As a hands-on learner, I also enjoy the opportunity to have extensive practical experience in our final years of medical school. Nevertheless, I think that both structures have their pros and cons and perhaps a student's success would depend on his/her learning style.
-JD
The Future of Canadian Healthcare
The grand rounds today was a very inspiring talk regarding the change Canada's healthcare needs.
Although Canada has a "universal healthcare", it's the worst "universal healthcare" that exists currently and we, as Canadians, need to recognize this and promote change. We can't just let ourselves be identified by our current medical system but push for an improvement because it's sub-optimal right now.
We need to help the politicians to not be too scared to implement change and make mistakes because these are necessary in change.
Change from the current healthcare system to one that's more community-based can also take power away from hospitals and physicians, but that's what revolution is and for the sake of truly patient-centered healthcare, we need to make steps toward it.
Of course, there's much more to improving our healthcare than what I've mentioned above, but this was a great time for me to think more about the future direction of our healthcare system and how I could contribute to it in the future.
-SC-
Although Canada has a "universal healthcare", it's the worst "universal healthcare" that exists currently and we, as Canadians, need to recognize this and promote change. We can't just let ourselves be identified by our current medical system but push for an improvement because it's sub-optimal right now.
We need to help the politicians to not be too scared to implement change and make mistakes because these are necessary in change.
Change from the current healthcare system to one that's more community-based can also take power away from hospitals and physicians, but that's what revolution is and for the sake of truly patient-centered healthcare, we need to make steps toward it.
Of course, there's much more to improving our healthcare than what I've mentioned above, but this was a great time for me to think more about the future direction of our healthcare system and how I could contribute to it in the future.
-SC-
Tuesday, March 20, 2018
Unneeded Fear
As a student of the Mississauga Academy of Medicine, I've done all of my core rotations in the Mississauga Hospitals. As a small community site, both hospitals provided collegiality and great learning by passionate preceptors. It also helped that often the preceptor to student ratio was 1:1.
I really enjoyed my time at the Mississauga hospitals, but I'd also developed a fear of the sites located downtown, mostly fueled by rumours and word of mouth. Talk of the strict hierarchy that's present at most hospitals and how us, medical students, were at the bottom of the ladder, scared me. I imagined very hectic environments with preceptors too busy to give a mere medical student any time, and being the bottom of a food chain where you're in a vulnerable position.
Today, I had my first TB clinic at TWH. It was an amazing working and learning environment, where my preceptor was a very chill, and super nice teacher, walking me step by step through the process of seeing a consult. The nurses were also terrific, being very patient with me as I learned the ropes and the most friendly people I've worked with. Even though I'm quite a reserved person, I immediately felt comfortable among the team and they really helped me to feel like I was a part of it.
Not only did I learn a lot about TB consultations at the clinic today, but I've realized how silly my worries were and what I can look forward to when I start my Family Medicine residency with the University of Toronto.
-SC-
I really enjoyed my time at the Mississauga hospitals, but I'd also developed a fear of the sites located downtown, mostly fueled by rumours and word of mouth. Talk of the strict hierarchy that's present at most hospitals and how us, medical students, were at the bottom of the ladder, scared me. I imagined very hectic environments with preceptors too busy to give a mere medical student any time, and being the bottom of a food chain where you're in a vulnerable position.
Today, I had my first TB clinic at TWH. It was an amazing working and learning environment, where my preceptor was a very chill, and super nice teacher, walking me step by step through the process of seeing a consult. The nurses were also terrific, being very patient with me as I learned the ropes and the most friendly people I've worked with. Even though I'm quite a reserved person, I immediately felt comfortable among the team and they really helped me to feel like I was a part of it.
Not only did I learn a lot about TB consultations at the clinic today, but I've realized how silly my worries were and what I can look forward to when I start my Family Medicine residency with the University of Toronto.
-SC-
Monday, March 5, 2018
Case-Based Learning
In my final blog
post, I am reflecting on the exposure that I have had to case-based learning (CBL)
during my selective. Throughout my
clinics and the lunch-time rounds, I have had the opportunity to listen in and
participate in the discussion as residents prepare for their Royal College examination
by going through practice cases. The scenarios
have ranged from topics within the various Internal Medicine subspecialties and
the practice questions always include asking the trainee to summarize the case
in one to two sentences. The next step
is to create a differential diagnosis (with their leading differential stated
upfront) and develop a preliminary management plan. Follow-up questions from preceptors may
surround counseling or altering the scenario to see how management plans may
differ under other circumstances. After
the trainee has completed the case, we talk as a group about how the scenario
went.
We use this
framework in CBL frequently and it stimulates fruitful discussion as it allows
group members to contribute and bounce ideas off of each other as to how they
would manage certain patient cases. It
is particularly useful as you put yourself in that situation and think about
what you would really do if you saw
that presentation in the emergency department or an outpatient setting.
CBL has been defined
by Thistlewaite et al. in 2012: “The goal of CBL is to prepare students for
clinical practice, through the use of authentic clinical cases. It links theory to practice, through the
application of knowledge to the cases, using inquiry-based learning methods.” (Thistlewaite et al., 2012) CBL allows for
the application of lecture material to practical scenarios. (Brown et al., 2012) In CBL, there may be
some advanced preparation and discovery is encouraged in such a way that both
students and facilitators share responsibility for coming to closure on key
clinical pearls. (Srinivasan et al.,
2007)
CBL is contrasted
with problem-based learning (PBL) which operates slightly differently and is more
open-ended and self-directed in which students must identify what they need to
know. In PBL, facilitators play a
minimal role and allow students to explore different avenues. (Srinivasan et al., 2007) When students work
together for PBL, the group will still be presented with a clinical case, but students
are allowed to define and struggle with the problem. (Srinivasan et al., 2007) PBL focuses on
discovery by learners to stimulate problem solving and critical thinking as
well as both independent learning and team learning. (Srinivasan et al., 2007)
The study in 2007 by
Srinivasan et al. at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and the
University of California, Davis (UCD) looked at the response of medical
students and faculty after a switch was made from PBL towards CBL. CBL was preferred by both students and
faculty, however those that did prefer PBL felt it encouraged self-directed
learning. (Srinivasan et al., 2007). In PBL though, it can be difficult to cover large
amounts of ground given the exploration component. (McLean, 2016) Whereas, CBL allows more focusing
on learning objectives and there is more emphasis on achieving a set outcome by
the end of the session. (McLean, 2016)
Both are advantageous to medical education and have unique aspects to offer.
Thanks for reading my posts!
SH
Resources:
1. Srinivasan, M. et al. (2007). Comparing Problem-Based Learning with
Case-Based Learning: Effects of a Major Curricular Shift at Two
Institutions. Academic Medicine, 82(1): 74 – 82.
2. Thistlewaite, J. E. et al. (2012). The effective of case based learning
in health professional education. A BEME
systematic review. BEME guide number 23.
Med Teach, 34: E421 – E444.
3. Mclean.
Case-Based learning and its Application in Medical and Health-Care Field: A Review
of Worldwide Literature. Journal of Medical Education and Curricular
Development 2016:3 39–49 doi:10.4137/JMecd.S20377.
4. Brown, K. et al. (2012). Case Based Learning Teaching Methodology in
Undergraduate Health Sciences. International Journal of Health Sciences,
2(2): 48 – 66.
Sunday, March 4, 2018
Patient-Centred Care
A theme that arose this week during both morning
report and my Rapid clinics was patient-centred care. During morning report, the senior from
overnight was summarizing the patients that were admitted. For each, we reviewed relevant clinical
pearls as well as how we could tie in patient-centred care. One of the patients that was admitted was receiving
nutrition via total parenteral nutrition (TPN) at home. The patient presented to hospital severely
dehydrated after missing a few days of TPN.
Rather than assuming the patient was not adherent, it was gathered on
history that she did understand the importance of TPN but was having difficulty
with it at home. The solution here that that
the team could implement on discharge would be to ensure that the patient had
adequate home supports and CCAC to help her with TPN. In scenarios like this, our role as care
providers involves exploring the barriers and obstacles that our patients face
in their health care journeys.
Patient-centred care has been defined as a concept
that integrates patient interests and the personal contexts of patients’ lives
into their care; their wishes are honoured and respected during their experiences
with the health care system. (Epstein et al., 2011) Epstein et al. discussed
some techniques that can been taken to accomplish this. For example, communication styles that invite
patients early on to ask questions about their conditions promotes this
concept. (Epstein et al., 2011) Patients and health care providers perceptions of an encounter
may be different. A recent study by
Montague et al. surveyed various health care professionals and the public to
identify factors that contribute to patient-centred care. (Montague et al., 2017) The public valued “timely
and readily accessed care” provided in a “caring respectful context” with decisions
made in partnership with patients and providers and with a framework that care
should be “based on need and not the ability to pay.” (Montague et al., 2017) Health care
professionals agreed with the above with an additional emphasis on “care
influenced by evidence and expert opinion.”
(Montague et al., 2017)
An example of patient-centred care that I encountered
was during my Rapid clinic in which we had a patient referred to us from the
Emergency Department with some abnormal enzymes on blood work. Upon further history and inquiring about
medications, it was apparent that the patient was consuming a number of additional
supplements that could be contributing to the blood work abnormalities. We went through all them in detail and counseled
the patient on our recommendations for what would be safe to take. While doing this, we kept in mind what he
valued in his life, what was important to him, and why he was consuming these
supplements in the first place. This
helped navigate the discussion and get to know the patient better.
My preceptors exemplified a number of qualities that
were helpful in providing effective patient-centred care, and I hope to emulate
them as I moved forward in my career.
SH
Resources:
1. Epstein, R. M. et al. (2011). The Values and Value of Patient-Centered
Care. Ann Fam Med, 9(2): 100 – 103.
2. Montague, T. et al. (2017).
Patient-Centred Care in Canada: Key Components and the Path Forward. Healthcare
Quarterly, 20(1): 50 – 56. doi:10.12927/hcq.2017.25136
An exercise in reflection
It seems like only yesterday I wrote my first reflective piece for this selective.
Fast forward a few weeks and here I am, writing my last! As a medical trainee, much of what I do is entrenched in a clinical context. Little of my day-to-day communication is an exercise in reflection.
My reflections these past few weeks have been both enriching and rewarding. They’ve helped me disconnect from the usual hustle and bustle of being a healthcare provider and instead, step back to re-evaluate my life with calm. I can describe my reflections best as a venture into mindfulness meditation: I’m more acutely aware of my daily activities and am able to better tease out the little things which make me frustrated, upset, content, or otherwise.
I hope this is a skill I can continue to cultivate as I move forward in my career. I’m certain it will be an asset, which can help me better recognize and regulate my own emotions amidst the inevitable chaos that will be residency at times. I’m thankful for all the new medical knowledge I’ve accrued over the past few weeks. Even more so, I’m grateful for developing a crucial new life skill.
Alice signing out!
Fast forward a few weeks and here I am, writing my last! As a medical trainee, much of what I do is entrenched in a clinical context. Little of my day-to-day communication is an exercise in reflection.
My reflections these past few weeks have been both enriching and rewarding. They’ve helped me disconnect from the usual hustle and bustle of being a healthcare provider and instead, step back to re-evaluate my life with calm. I can describe my reflections best as a venture into mindfulness meditation: I’m more acutely aware of my daily activities and am able to better tease out the little things which make me frustrated, upset, content, or otherwise.
I hope this is a skill I can continue to cultivate as I move forward in my career. I’m certain it will be an asset, which can help me better recognize and regulate my own emotions amidst the inevitable chaos that will be residency at times. I’m thankful for all the new medical knowledge I’ve accrued over the past few weeks. Even more so, I’m grateful for developing a crucial new life skill.
Alice signing out!
Match Day Relief and Grief
On 12 pm March 1st, I matched to my top residency choice in Toronto’s Family Medicine! It was gratifying to be recognized by the program for all the hard work I’ve put in these past few years. I believe it was a culmination of research, community outreach work, and clinical excellence, which helped distinguish my application. It’s humbling to be accepted into a class of hardworking and compassionate future residents. The best part of all this is that many of my good medical school friends are also in my cohort! It’ll be exciting to embark on the next phase of this journey with familiar and friendly faces. I promised to serve my patients with integrity and dedication. I hope to fulfill that promise over the years to come.
Reaching out to current residents, my understanding is that a subsequent internal match will occur over the next few months to determine where my training site will be. I’ve heard positive things about all sites but NYGH has a special place in my heart. It’s where I did many of my rotations in medical school and where I’ve come to familiarize myself with many of the staff in the Family Medicine Teaching Unit. Keeping in mind it’s a very competitive site, I hope to train there during the next 2 years. I’ve also been encouraged by others to apply for my CPSO postgraduate training license and CMPA coverage early on. Many residents have warned me about the mountain of paperwork that is headed my way. Having just endured an arduous match process, I feel the administrative work will be a cakewalk. I feel relief at the prospect of being able to complete it!
On the other hand, I know Match Day is a time filled with grief for those students who went unmatched. Some of those unfortunate few are classmates and friends who I know very well. I’m aware of how hard they worked and recognize that today marks a time when the field they are so keen to join has not validated their efforts. For these students, it must be heartbreaking to hear such news. Even more disturbing is the news that 26 students in my class and 222 students failed to match on a national level. This is an unprecedented number and highlights intrinsic failure in the medical training system to support students in their dreams of becoming practicing physicians. It’s unfathomable that years of hard work to enter and graduate from medical school in addition to thousands of dollars of subsidies from public taxpayers will hang in the balance. As a specialty, we must ensure all Canadian medical grads have an option to continue their education so that our system continues to nurture the growth of caring and compassionate physicians.
- AX
Reaching out to current residents, my understanding is that a subsequent internal match will occur over the next few months to determine where my training site will be. I’ve heard positive things about all sites but NYGH has a special place in my heart. It’s where I did many of my rotations in medical school and where I’ve come to familiarize myself with many of the staff in the Family Medicine Teaching Unit. Keeping in mind it’s a very competitive site, I hope to train there during the next 2 years. I’ve also been encouraged by others to apply for my CPSO postgraduate training license and CMPA coverage early on. Many residents have warned me about the mountain of paperwork that is headed my way. Having just endured an arduous match process, I feel the administrative work will be a cakewalk. I feel relief at the prospect of being able to complete it!
On the other hand, I know Match Day is a time filled with grief for those students who went unmatched. Some of those unfortunate few are classmates and friends who I know very well. I’m aware of how hard they worked and recognize that today marks a time when the field they are so keen to join has not validated their efforts. For these students, it must be heartbreaking to hear such news. Even more disturbing is the news that 26 students in my class and 222 students failed to match on a national level. This is an unprecedented number and highlights intrinsic failure in the medical training system to support students in their dreams of becoming practicing physicians. It’s unfathomable that years of hard work to enter and graduate from medical school in addition to thousands of dollars of subsidies from public taxpayers will hang in the balance. As a specialty, we must ensure all Canadian medical grads have an option to continue their education so that our system continues to nurture the growth of caring and compassionate physicians.
- AX
Saturday, March 3, 2018
Advocating on behalf of our patients
Patient advocacy is such an integral part of a physician’s work and responsibilities. It is recognized officially as one of the seven CanMED roles and unofficially as a core competency of being a physician. In the past, I had always witnessed or delivered patient advocacy in a way to help fight the inequity in our health care system. Today, I experienced something different.
I had the opportunity to work in the fast-paced Dermatology clinic. Having multiple learners in the packed schedule left the staff little time to catch her breath from one appointment to the next. My last patient was a lady in her late 50s suffering from a recent flare-up of her “old eczema”. She said she had been referred to a Dermatologist previously but only had a “5 minutes appointment” with the specialist and was prescribed some topical steroid creams to use. However, she did not have the chance to talk to the specialist about her concerns regarding steroid side effects, so she only used it sparingly in the past several months. When she did use the topical ointments, she got temporary relief from them but had little improvement in her symptoms overall. She also since had been using her own DIY cream to soothe her skin, which she was quite proud of. Ultimately, she was happy about the topical steroid ointments and wanted to have another prescription since she’d just ran out of them.
When we examined the patient, her rashes resembled the typical eczema presentations in certain areas, but there were also large sections of severely inflamed papulosquamous rashes over her trunk. The most “efficient way” of handling this appointment would be to agree with her previous diagnosis and prescribe more of the steroid creams since the patient was satisfied with her treatment. However, my preceptor didn’t dismiss the patient’s unusual presentation and suggested a punch biopsy to delineate the pathology further. She then spent time addressing the patient’s concerns regarding steroid side effects. At the end of the appointment, the patient agreed to step up her steroid to a higher potency so that her therapy would be more effective and understood that a shorter duration of steroid therapy would translate to fewer side effects.
What my preceptor did today demonstrated a form of health advocacy that rarely gets complimented. She was not happy settling on delivering patient care that would be regarded as “just good enough”. Even when our patient was content with her symptoms being sub-optimally controlled, my preceptor believed that she deserved better care by trying to pursue further investigations and spent the time to address her concerns. It’s worthwhile noting the everyday heroes in our field and celebrating their devotion and dedication to patient care whenever we can.
-AX
I had the opportunity to work in the fast-paced Dermatology clinic. Having multiple learners in the packed schedule left the staff little time to catch her breath from one appointment to the next. My last patient was a lady in her late 50s suffering from a recent flare-up of her “old eczema”. She said she had been referred to a Dermatologist previously but only had a “5 minutes appointment” with the specialist and was prescribed some topical steroid creams to use. However, she did not have the chance to talk to the specialist about her concerns regarding steroid side effects, so she only used it sparingly in the past several months. When she did use the topical ointments, she got temporary relief from them but had little improvement in her symptoms overall. She also since had been using her own DIY cream to soothe her skin, which she was quite proud of. Ultimately, she was happy about the topical steroid ointments and wanted to have another prescription since she’d just ran out of them.
When we examined the patient, her rashes resembled the typical eczema presentations in certain areas, but there were also large sections of severely inflamed papulosquamous rashes over her trunk. The most “efficient way” of handling this appointment would be to agree with her previous diagnosis and prescribe more of the steroid creams since the patient was satisfied with her treatment. However, my preceptor didn’t dismiss the patient’s unusual presentation and suggested a punch biopsy to delineate the pathology further. She then spent time addressing the patient’s concerns regarding steroid side effects. At the end of the appointment, the patient agreed to step up her steroid to a higher potency so that her therapy would be more effective and understood that a shorter duration of steroid therapy would translate to fewer side effects.
What my preceptor did today demonstrated a form of health advocacy that rarely gets complimented. She was not happy settling on delivering patient care that would be regarded as “just good enough”. Even when our patient was content with her symptoms being sub-optimally controlled, my preceptor believed that she deserved better care by trying to pursue further investigations and spent the time to address her concerns. It’s worthwhile noting the everyday heroes in our field and celebrating their devotion and dedication to patient care whenever we can.
-AX
Wednesday, February 28, 2018
The Practical Elements of Practice
This week I was in the General Respirology clinic and had the opportunity
to see a number of patients with obstructive lung disease. There were a variety of pathologies including
asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), asthma-COPD overlap
syndrome (ACOS), and alpha-1 antitrypsin (AAT) deficiency leading to COPD. Before seeing patients, they were each
evaluated in the pulmonary function lab with full pulmonary function testing
(PFT’s).
As a team, we were reflecting on the fact that several patients who have
never had formal PFT’s may be labelled as COPD patients. As a team, we were discussing that it would
be fruitful to have spirometry upfront when patients present to hospital in the
Emergency Department with respiratory distress.
That would be feasible given that we have respiratory therapists that can
perform this for us on-call. One
downside is that if spirometry is performed when patients are acutely unwell
then it may not be a marker of their best performance. However, the benefits would be that having
spirometry both at the beginning of admission and after admission for
comparison would aid in assessing whether there is reversibility or improvement
in their lung function. Another consequence
of not having a sense of a patient’s lung function upfront is that patients may
be treated for an exacerbation of COPD but may not in fact have obstructive
lung disease. The average overall cost
of a severe AECOPD is $9,557 given that it includes a hospitalization. (Mittmann
et al., 2008) Therefore, if we can determine with early spirometry that a patient
does not truly have obstructive lung disease, this can minimize their cost of
inhalers and hospitalizations. The cost
of obtaining spirometry is less than $100.
(Choosing Wisely, 2014)
On the other hand, resource management also includes being judicious
when ordering tests that may be expensive when the index of suspicion of a
certain pathology is low. For example, a
sleep study is an expensive test and the American Association of Sleep Medicine
and the American Board of Internal Medicine released guidelines on five things
to know before ordering polysomnography and for treating sleep disorders. (Choosing
Wisely, 2014)
At the Yale University School of Medicine, a session in the format of
Morning Report was implemented to demonstrate the costs associated with work-up
of clinical cases. (Fogerty et al.,
2014) The session was found to be useful in learning the impact of medical
decision-making and promoting more realistic clinical work-up. (Fogerty et al., 2014) The importance of learning
about resource management is a topic that I have had the chance to reflect on
throughout my selective. We work in a
system with a finite number of resources and it essential to appropriately order
tests given their cost and utility and consider such factors in addition to
your clinical assessment when making decisions.
SH
Resources:
Mittmann, N., Kuramoto, L., Seung, S.J., Haddon,
J.M., Bradley- Kennedy, C. & Fitzgerald, J.M. (2008). The cost of moderate
and severe COPD exacerbations to the Canadian healthcare system. Respiratory
Medicine, 102, 413-421. Retrieved at http://www.resmedjournal.com/article/S0954-6111(07)00432-5/pdf
Choosing Wisely. (2014).
Spirometry for Asthma. Choosing Wisely,
An initiative of the ABIM Foundation. Retrieved at http://www.choosingwisely.org/patient-resources/spirometry-for-asthma/
Accessed on March 1, 2018
Robert L. Fogerty ,
Jason J. Heavner , John P. Moriarty , Andre N. Sofair & Grace Jenq (2014)
Novel Integration of Systems-Based Practice Into Internal Medicine Residency
Programs: The Interactive Cost- Awareness Resident Exercise (I-CARE), Teaching and
Learning in Medicine: An International Journal, 26:1, 90-94, DOI:
10.1080/10401334.2013.857338
Choosing Wisely. (2014). American Academy of Sleep Medicine: Five
Things Physicians and Patients Should Question. Choosing
Wisely, An initiative of the ABIM Foundation. Retrieved at http://www.choosingwisely.org/societies/american-academy-of-sleep-medicine/
Accessed on March 1, 2018
Sunday, February 25, 2018
Learning to be a Teacher
On Friday afternoon, I
gave a 30-minute teaching session for the third-year clinical clerks (CC3’s) on
blood films using four cases as a framework: Hodgkin’s lymphoma, multiple
myeloma, thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP), and acute myeloid leukemia.
My aim was to target the teaching
session towards their upcoming Internal Medicine Objective Structured Clinical
Examination (OSCE). The purpose of an OSCE
is to have objective criteria by which to evaluate the clinical competence of
trainees and their overall interaction with patients. It has been shown in literature that the OSCE
also evaluates areas such as communication skills and being able to handle
unpredictable patient interactions. (Zayyan,
2011). In Internal Medicine clerkship, both Faculty and students have indicated
that incorporation of an OSCE motivates them and provides opportunities to reflect
on learning. (Cruzeiro & Bollela, 2014)
During my teaching
session, to address their upcoming exam, I tried to go through Q&A in a
structured format. I asked the CC3’s a
variety of sequential questions for each case such as what questions they would
ask on history of presenting illness, which physical examination maneuvers
would be important, investigations and interpretation of the blood film or biopsy,
and what their differential diagnoses were.
One of the challenges of physical examinations is that a focused
physical examination for a complaint may actually involve multiple organ
systems and having an approach is important.
One of the mock cases in my teaching session was the first case on
Hodgkin’s lymphoma. In the scenario, the
patient presented with a neck lump and constitutional symptoms. We reviewed the lymph node examination and
the names of the nodal regions that should be palpated as well as the
concerning features. In addition,
organomegaly would be part of a focused physical examination here and this
allowed us to discuss the JAMA Rational Clinical Examination for splenic
enlargement. These cases also provided
us with an opportunity to revisit the pathophysiology of these disease states and
how the conditions are managed.
Thinking back to some
of the experiences that I have had, there are several techniques for teaching that
are engaging. I particularly enjoyed the
EBM rounds that we had earlier in this selective, in which we critically analyzed
a paper on edoxaban for the treatment of cancer-associated venous thromboembolism. We split up into smaller groups within a
large audience to answer a subset of questions before reconvening and sharing
our analyses. Other techniques that work
well include the team-based Jeopardy at morning report, hands-on learning such
as with a simulator like Harvey, and the use of online surveys (or Student
Response Systems/iClickers) such as the one used in the Harm Reductions
lunch-time rounds to gauge medical professionals’ opinions and practices. There are several creative ways to engage
audiences when teaching and I hope to incorporate some of these strategies next
time I get to teach!
SH
Resources:
Zayyan, M. (2011).
Objective Structured Clinical Examination: The Assessment of Choice. Oman Med J, 26(4): 219 – 222.
Cruzeiro, M. & V.
Bollela. (2014). Faculty development of an OSCE in an internal medicine
clerkship. Medical Education, 48(5):
545 – 546. DOI: 10.1111/medu.12472
The Art of Medicine
This past Thursday I
spent the day in the Dermatology Clinic.
It was a special day for rounds that occurs once a month, in which dermatologists
from the hospital bring outpatients that they have been following to be reviewed
by the whole team. The cases were
undifferentiated and challenging and no formal diagnosis had been made
yet. As a group of medical students,
residents, and attending physicians, we moved from one room to the next to see
all of the patients. In each room, we
huddled around the patient, listened to the treating physician’s summary of the
case and members of the Dermatology team asked any other relevant questions on
history and examined the patient.
After seeing all of
the patients, we sat around a table over lunch and discussed each case in
detail, creating a differential diagnosis and an appropriate management plan
for each. The purpose was to pool
everyone together and hear the input and opinions of several
dermatologists. At the end, a few of the
final diagnoses were still somewhat uncertain but the goal of the discussion was
to ensure that any worrisome and/or common diagnoses were being considered and
that the possible avenues for therapeutic intervention had been trialled.
It was a unique
learning opportunity for me to hear the thought processes of the team as they made
decisions. One of the cases was
challenging given that most of the patient’s symptoms had resolved and it was
difficult to make an assessment. The
patient had alopecia as per a few scalp biopsies, however the hair
loss pattern did not neatly fit into one of our known alopecia diagnoses. The discussion
was centred around how to prevent this from happening again given the
uncertainty of the cause. Other patients
had nail changes: one case was non-uniform nail hyperpigmentation NYD which was
a nuisance for the patient, but there were no concerning features on examination
and not likely to be any treatments for this.
Medicine is an art and making decisions with a team can often aid in
determining the extent of a work-up, solidifying a diagnosis, knowing when to refer,
and knowing when to treat.
Bedside rounding is
particularly useful in a field like this where much of the learning and
examination is done visually. It creates
an environment to learn from each other’s experiences and improve outcomes through combined decision-making and team consensus. (Gonzalo et al., 2013) It has been shown
that on internal medicine wards, patients receiving bedside rounds prefer this
method. (Gonzalo et al., 2010) During
our Dermatology team rounds, one of the patients had nail findings similar to
onychogryphosis but with some differing features. She was encouraged that we were all at the
bedside trying to help figure out why this had happened. Team rounding at the bedside not only is an
important educational tool as a trainee, but it also reinforces the importance
of patient-centred care in medicine.
Stay tuned for more,
SH
Resources:
Gonzalo, J. D. et al.
(2013). The Value of Bedside Rounds: A Multicenter Qualitative Study. Teaching and Learning in Medicine,
25(4): 326 – 333. doi:
10.1080/10401334.2013.830514.
Gonzalo, J. D. et al.
(2010). The Return of Bedside Rounds: An Educational Intervention. J Gen
Intern Med, 25(8): 792 – 798. doi: 10.1007/s11606-010-1344-7
Saturday, February 24, 2018
Transition to Residency
Transition to Residency
On Wednesday I was on
the hospitalist medicine team for General Internal Medicine (GIM). On the team, there was the attending staff, a
fellow that was doing Emergency Department (ED) consults with me and ICU
transfers, and another fellow rounding on the team’s inpatients. This was a
unique experience for me as it was the first time that I have been involved in
day-time ED consults and admissions for GIM.
It is entirely different as you have many of the day-time resources
available and this changes the options you have available for patients’ disposition
plans.
One of the cases that
I saw was a patient who presented with symptoms of a few days of lower
limb pain. Despite the pain,
she was improving and was still ambulating.
After doing my consult, she brought up to me that she did not have
coverage for hospital costs or medications.
As I was coming up with my plan before reviewing with my staff, I was
thinking about how to best balance a few things: the patient’s wishes, what we
think may be medically necessary, and resources. When ordering further investigations, we
thought carefully about the rationale for our tests and which ones are
medically necessary and would change our management. For example, ordering a lower leg ultrasound
to rule out a deep vein thrombosis was something that was acutely relevant. In terms of a connective disease work-up, we
ordered a few higher yield investigations but an entire work-up at present was
not warranted given the clinical picture.
We had one of our
subspecialists see the patient and their team deemed that this was a transient
episode, and we planned for her discharge from the ED. In managing this patient throughout the day,
I felt that I had a lot of resources at my disposal to make a safe discharge
plan while considering her situation holistically (namely her health coverage
limitations) and still ruling out worrisome causes of her presentation. Our social worker came by to see her with
regard to providing resources to cover her hospital costs. I counselled the patient on reasons to return
to the ED and gave her a list of over-the-counter pain medications that she can
use (with maximum doses and side effects explained). She had the contact information of a
subspecialist in case her symptoms did not improve.
Making safe decisions with
regard to admission versus discharge and counselling patients are skills that
develop over time and I was afforded the opportunity to practice that during my
day on hospitalist medicine.
Transitioning to residency will be challenging as we develop more
autonomy and responsibility – there will be more difficult conversations and decision-making
on a regular basis. A study from UCSF’s
School of Medicine, looking at their transition to residency course, showed
that students found the course helpful for: recognizing unstable or sick
patients, identifying help and backup, communicating effectively, teaching
others, maintaining well-being, understanding resources, and carrying out daily
patient care responsibilities. (Teo et
al., 2011) This highlights the importance of our current Transition to
Residency course which includes lectures, rotations, and assignment thats have
a large impact on preparing us for what is to come!
SH
Resources:
Teo, A. R. et al.
(2011). The Key Role of a Transition Course in Preparing Medical Students for
Internship. Acad Med, 86(7): 860 – 865.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)